
"Cheryl Wright" Pick the Divisions (2003)
The Results
Freddy 16
Cheryl W. 19
Jay Pinho 20
Bill F. 23
Kenny Poulin 24
The Baba 24
Mac Callahan 26
Mitchell Aster26
Bob-Nob 28
Rick Delahunty28
Ken 28
Steve Souza 30
MHerve 33
Steve Robbins 34
Richard Smith 36
McDuck 36
SOMLAW 40
A few observations; Bob-Nob, Jay Pinho, and Cheryl were the only ones
who nailed two divisions exactly right. Freddy's win was due to his
consistancy...he had only the AL West right, but was very close in
every other divison. Yours truly was the only one to pick the tricky
AL Central correctly. No one got the NL East right...in fact, most of
us got our asses kicked there (Mitchell Aster and Steve Souza came
closest). For what it's worth, the consensus picks of the Baseball
Prospectus gang would have earned them a 21!
1. RULES: submit to redsoxmonthly@aol.com (DON'T POST to the ng) the
outcomes of the six division races, 1-6 (or 1-5, 1-4 as the case may
be). At the end of the year, I'll tally the results and declare the
winner based on overall accuracy. All entries must be received before
the first pitch of the first game (hey, and the Mariners start early in
Japan, right?)
2.METHOD: Like golf or STD tag, the lowest score wins. For each place
your prediction misses, you're given one point, ie, you pick the Twins
for third and they win the AL Central, you get two points.
3. JUDGING: Well, it's simple math. What I'll do is forward each entry
to another ng member to verify the entry; Steve Robbins has volunteered
to assist, and post the entries on his website for all to ponder after
Opening Day. I do this verifying because I want to enter as well, and I
don't want to be accused of 'sandbagging' by reviewing all your choices
first. Well, little chance of that happening, anyway, I came in
next-to-last in 2002.
4. PRIZE: The pride in showing off your superior intellect (an apparent
bonus in this ng) and the privilage of having the contest named after
you next year; hence, the name of this year's contest!
Summary - Average Voted Position
| AL East |
Boston
|
New York
|
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| Avg Pos |
1.41 |
1.59 |
3.24 |
4.12 |
4.65 |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Minnesota |
Cleveland |
Kansas City
|
Detroit
|
. |
| Avg Pos |
1.41 |
1.76 |
3.0
|
4.06 |
4.76 |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Anaheim
|
Seattle
|
Texas
|
. |
. |
| Avg Pos |
1.41 |
2.18
|
3.0
|
3.41 |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia
|
Atlanta
|
New York
|
Montreal
|
Florida
|
. |
| Avg Pos |
1.29 |
2.06
|
3.29 |
4.0
|
4.35 |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Houston |
Cincinnati |
Chicago |
Pittsburgh
|
Milwaukee |
| Avg Pos |
1.71 |
2.24 |
3.12 |
3.35 |
4.71
|
5.88 |
| NL West |
Arizona |
San Francisco |
Los Angeles
|
San Diego
|
Colorado |
. |
| Avg Pos |
1.82 |
1.82 |
2.41 |
4.41 |
4.53 |
. |
Highest voted position: Philadelphia with 13 firsts, 3 seconds, and 1
third.
Lowest voted position: Milwaukee with 15 sixths and 2 fifths in a six
team division.
Mitchell Aster
| AL East |
New York |
Boston |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Minnesota |
Cleveland |
Detroit |
Kansas City |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Anaheim |
Texas |
Seattle |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
Florida |
Atlanta |
Montreal |
New York |
. |
| NL Central |
Houston |
Cincinnati |
Chicago |
St Louis |
Milwaukee |
Pittsburgh |
| NL West |
San Francisco |
Los Angeles |
Arizona |
San Diego |
Colorado |
. |
Bill (Red Sox Monthly)
| AL East |
Boston |
New York |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Minnesota |
Chicago |
Kansas City |
Cleveland |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Anaheim |
Seattle |
Texas |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
Atlanta |
Montreal |
Florida |
New York |
. |
| NL Central |
Houston |
St Louis |
Cincinnati |
Pittsburgh |
Chicago |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
Arizona |
San Francisco |
Los Angeles |
San Diego |
Colorado |
. |
Bob-Nob
| AL East |
New York |
Boston |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Minnesota |
Chicago |
Cleveland |
Kansas City |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Seattle |
Anaheim |
Texas |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
Montreal |
Atlanta |
New York |
Florida |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Houston |
Cincinnati |
Chicago |
Pittsburgh |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
Arizona |
Los Angeles |
San Francisco |
Colorado |
San Diego |
. |
Mac Callahan
| AL East |
New York |
Boston |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Cleveland |
Minnesota |
Kansas City |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Anaheim |
Texas |
Seattle |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Atlanta |
Philadelphia |
Montreal |
New York |
Florida |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Chicago |
Houston |
Cincinnati |
Pittsburgh |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
Arizona |
San Francisco |
Los Angeles |
Colorado |
San Diego |
. |
Rick Delahanty
| AL East |
Boston |
New York
|
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Minnesota |
Chicago
|
Cleveland
|
Kansas City |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Anaheim |
Seattle |
Texas
|
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia
|
New York
|
Atlanta
|
Montreal |
Florida |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Houston
|
Chicago
|
Cincinnati |
Pittsburgh |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
San Francisco
|
Arizona
|
San Diego
|
Los Angeles
|
Colorado
|
. |
Freddy
| AL East |
New York |
Boston |
Baltimore |
Toronto |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Minnesota |
Cleveland |
Kansas City |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Seattle |
Anaheim |
Texas |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Atlanta |
Philadelphia |
New York |
Montreal |
Florida |
. |
| NL Central |
Chicago |
Houston |
St Louis |
Cincinnati |
Pittsburgh |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
San Francisco |
Arizona |
Los Angeles |
Colorado |
San Diego |
. |
Ken
| AL East |
Boston |
New York |
Toronto |
Tampa Bay |
Baltimore |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Minnesota |
Kansas City |
Cleveland |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Anaheim |
Oakland |
Seattle |
Texas |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
Atlanta |
New York |
Montreal |
Florida |
. |
| NL Central |
Houston |
St Louis |
Chicago |
Pittsburgh |
Cincinnati |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
Arizona |
San Francisco |
Los Angeles |
San Diego |
Colorado |
. |
McDuck
| AL East |
Boston |
New York |
Toronto
|
Baltimore
|
Tampa Bay
|
. |
| AL Central |
Minnesota |
Cleveland
|
Chicago
|
Detroit
|
Kansas City
|
. |
| AL West |
Anaheim |
Seattle
|
Oakland |
Texas
|
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
Atlanta |
New York
|
Florida |
Montreal |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Cincinnati |
Houston
|
Chicago
|
Pittsburgh
|
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
Arizona
|
Los Angeles |
San Francisco
|
San Diego
|
Colorado
|
. |
MHerve
| AL East |
Boston |
New York |
Toronto
|
Tampa Bay |
Baltimore |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Minnesota |
Kansas City |
Cleveland |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Anaheim |
Texas |
Oakland |
Seattle |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
New York |
Atlanta |
Florida |
Montreal |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Cincinnati |
Chicago |
Pittsburgh |
Houston |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
San Francisco |
Los Angeles |
Arizona |
Colorado |
San Diego |
. |
Jay Pinho
| AL East |
New York |
Boston |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Minnesota |
Cleveland |
Kansas City |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Seattle |
Anaheim |
Texas |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Atlanta |
New York |
Philadelphia |
Florida |
Montreal |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Houston |
Cincinnati |
Pittsburgh |
Chicago |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
Los Angeles |
San Francisco |
Arizona |
Colorado |
San Diego |
. |
Kenny Poulin
| AL East |
New York |
Boston |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Minnesota |
Cleveland |
Kansas City |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Anaheim |
Seattle |
Texas |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
Atlanta |
New York |
Montreal |
Florida |
. |
| NL Central |
Houston |
St Louis |
Chicago |
Cincinnati |
Pittsburgh |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
San Francisco |
Arizona |
Los Angeles |
San Diego |
Colorado |
. |
Steve Robbins
| AL East |
Boston |
New York |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Minnesota |
Cleveland |
Kansas City |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Texas |
Anaheim |
Seattle |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
Atlanta |
New York |
Montreal |
Florida |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Cincinnati |
Houston |
Pittsburgh |
Chicago |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
Arizona |
Los Angeles |
San Francisco |
San Diego |
Colorado |
. |
Richard Smith
| AL East |
Boston |
New York |
Tampa Bay |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Minnesota |
Cleveland |
Detroit |
Kansas City |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Anaheim |
Texas |
Seattle |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
Atlanta |
Florida |
New York |
Montreal |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Cincinnati |
Chicago |
Houston |
Pittsburgh |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
Arizona |
Los Angeles |
San Francisco |
Colorado |
San Diego |
. |
SOMLAW
| AL East |
Boston |
New York |
Tampa Bay |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Minnesota |
Cleveland |
Kansas City |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Anaheim |
Oakland |
Texas |
Seattle |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
New York |
Atlanta |
Montreal |
Florida |
. |
| NL Central |
Houston |
Cincinnati |
Pittsburgh |
St Louis |
Chicago |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
Arizona |
San Francisco |
Los Angeles |
San Diego |
Colorado |
. |
Steven Souza
| AL East |
Boston |
New York |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Chicago |
Cleveland |
Minnesota |
Detroit |
Kansas City |
. |
| AL West |
Seattle |
Oakland |
Texas |
Anaheim |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Atlanta |
Philadelphia |
Florida |
New York |
Montreal |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Chicago |
Cincinnati |
Houston |
Milwaukee |
Pittsburgh |
| NL West |
Los Angeles |
San Francisco |
Arizona |
Colorado |
San Diego |
. |
The Baba
| AL East |
Boston |
New York |
Baltimore |
Toronto |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Minnesota |
Chicago |
Cleveland |
Kansas City |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Anaheim |
Texas |
Seattle |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Atlanta |
Philadelphia |
Montreal |
New York |
Florida |
. |
| NL Central |
Houston |
St Louis |
Chicago |
Cincinnati |
Pittsburgh |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
San Francisco |
Los Angeles |
Arizona |
San Diego |
Colorado |
. |
Cheryl Wright
| AL East |
New York |
Boston |
Toronto |
Baltimore |
Tampa Bay |
. |
| AL Central |
Minnesota |
Chicago |
Cleveland |
Kansas City |
Detroit |
. |
| AL West |
Oakland |
Seattle |
Anaheim |
Texas |
. |
. |
| NL East |
Philadelphia |
Atlanta |
New York |
Montreal |
Florida |
. |
| NL Central |
St Louis |
Houston |
Chicago |
Cincinnati |
Pittsburgh |
Milwaukee |
| NL West |
San Francisco |
Arizona |
Los Angeles |
Colorado |
San Diego |
. |
For reference, I will put links to the predictions from major or
Boston newspapers and sports sites. Send me any links you find and I
will add them.
Baseball
Prospectus (Bower, Carroll, Hildebrand, Huckabay, Keri, Olkin,
Pappas, Scherer, Sheehan, Silver, Spira, Wilkins, Zumsteg)
CBS Sportsline
(Miller, McCarthy, Reich, Mack, Cockcroft)
ESPN
(Stark, Gammons, Neyer, Caple, Kurkjian, Reynold, Campbell, Candiotti,
Gwynn, Ravetch, Dibble, Sutcliffe, Brantley, Ridge, Szefc, Karabell,
Funston, Klapisch, Huckabay, Rogers, Schwartz, Sickels. Pike, Sutter,
Lipman)